Gmat句子改错题.To Josephine Baker,Paris was her home long before

问题描述:

Gmat句子改错题.
To Josephine Baker,Paris was her home long before it was fashionable to be an expatriate,and she remained in France during the Second World War as a performer and an intelligence agent for the Resistance.
(A) To Josephine Baker,Paris was her home long before it was fashionable to be an expatriate,
(B) For Josephine Baker,long before it was fashionable to be an expatriate,Paris was her home,
(C) Josephine Baker made Paris her home long before to be an expatriate was fashionable,
(D) Long before it was fashionable to be an expatriate,Josephine Baker made Paris her home,
(E) Long before it was fashionable being an expatriate,Paris was home to Josephine Baker,
看解释里说因为后面的句子and she remained主语是she,所以前面的句子的主语也必须是she,也就是Josephine才平行.但是这两个句子中间不是有一个连词and吗?就应该是两个独立的句子吧?为甚么一定要主语一致?我感觉和其他题里面的名词和名词平行,动名词和动名词平行不属于一个范畴呢.
还有C选项主语一致,为什么错啊?
1个回答 分类:英语 2014-12-14

问题解答:

我来补答
C和D的主语都是Josephine Baker.
C选项里before to be an expatriate was fashionable的表达方式没有D好.一般不定式加形容词的组合很少见,通常表示客观事实.如果用于表达过去发生的动作,通常是错误的.
如果有哪里不明白的话可以继续问~
再问: 就是第一个问题,为什么一定要两个句子的主语一致啊?但是这两个句子中间不是有一个连词and就应该是两个独立的句子吗?我感觉这和其他考平行的题目比如名词和名词平行,动名词和动名词平行不一样。
再答: 我晕,不一致那she指代就有问题了。如选项A,she默认指代paris,逻辑意思错。句子改错如果考的是语法知识就应该叫grammar而不是sentence correction了。而且真考语法那中国人学12年语法绝对无解的,秒杀老外。 这里所说的主语是逻辑主语。考的是一致性。非要从语法结构来说,and连接的是两个独立的句子,但是不是两个毫无关联的句子,而是两个并列的句子。如果是两个毫无关联的句子,一样错。 句子改错里一个句子读下来没明显错误,没歧义,不罗嗦就行了。 另外做句子改错完全按照题目给的提示来就对了。这题划线后面来一个she,就说明前面句子主语必须是个人。 我突然发现我之前回答过你关于句子改错的问题。。。真心建议你去CD下一个千行刷个5遍再继续做题。
 
 
展开全文阅读
剩余:2000