where did you graduate?还是where did you graduate from?

问题描述:

where did you graduate?还是where did you graduate from?
where 作为副词,当谓语是不及物动词的时候,是不是应该省略掉动词后的介词呢?
还是有疑问...这样好了,选出你觉得正确的句子:
1.where did you graduate?
2.where did you graduate from?
3.which school did you graduate from?
4.where do you live?
5.where do you live in?
我把这几个句子放在一起是有原因的哦.
1个回答 分类:英语 2014-10-23

问题解答:

我来补答
副词前不用加介词了,很简单的例子,go to school 和 go home,home是副词.
我感觉不用太多的考虑“当谓语是不及物动词的时候”如果总是在考虑这些东西的话,张口说英语时,会很难反应.语感的培养,不管是在口语交际还是阅读写作,都有很大的帮助.在考虑一个句子时,拘泥于语法太多也不好.
把上面两句变成陈述句来检验就可以了.
You graduated here.
you graduated from here.
很明显的可以看出第二句是不对的.
应该改为you gratuated from school.
特殊疑问句:Which school did you gra...from?
希望有所帮助.
补充:似乎只有我一个人持这种看法,大家都认为后一句对,因此我为了我的观点,需要补充:After he graduated high school,he joined the Army.
此例句源于Cambridge Advanced Learner's Dictionary.
而针对where do you come from,come from确实是词组,这一点在剑桥字典里体现得很明白.come from somewhere/sth (ORIGINATE) phrasal verb
to be born,obtained from,or made in a particular place:
She comes from Italy.
Some of the best wines come from France.
Does that quote come from Shakespeare?
She could hear banging coming from the room upstairs.
Where will the money for the project come from?
但是,graduate from并不在这个字典认定的词组范围内.因此,不能笼统地说这两个词可以套用.
大家可以去查一下剑桥字典.另外我又查了美国英英,graduate from 同样不在它所认定的词组范围内.
关于补充问题的回答:我直接去查剑桥,然后就出现了答案:例句里的第一个就是了.
live (HAVE A HOME) verb
1 live in/at,etc.to have your home somewhere:
Where do you live?
We live in London.
Some students live on the University campus.
He lives with four other people in a shared house.
俺选1 3 4 我想我大概明白您是在哪里觉得迷糊了.
欢迎大家讨论.
 
 
展开全文阅读
剩余:2000
上一页:合外力做功,